Mailing List Archive

Hi Doka,

Is there a specific reason why you are using the following syntax for the BGP policy to add the communities ?

community set "3254:65535 3254:9100";
community add "3524:9111";

I’m using the following in my policies :

entry entry-5 {
If {
nlri 123.123.128.0/21 exact ;
}
then {
med set 0;
local-preference 250;
community add "51088:6543" ;
community add "51088:65001" ;
permit ;
}
}

And that works on 12.4.2 , 12.4.3, 12.5.4. (and is currently broken in the 12.6.x beta but expected to be fixed before the 12.6 GA version.)
I’m also running X480’s .

Regards,
Erik Bais



From: extreme-nsp-bounces@puck.nether.net [mailto:extreme-nsp-bounces@puck.nether.net] On Behalf Of Volodymyr Litovka
Sent: Monday, July 18, 2011 12:35 PM
To: extreme-nsp@puck.nether.net
Cc: yokodzun@yokodzun.kiev.ua
Subject: [e-nsp] ExOS: "sh bgp routes community" bug?

Hi,

when looking into detailed network info, it shows right communities here:

eel.35 # sh bgp routes detail network 31.41.120.0/21

Feasible Routes
---------------
Route: 31.41.120.0/21, Peer 213.133.164.149, BEST, Active
Origin IGP, Next-Hop 213.133.164.149, LPref 95, MED 100
Weight 1,
AS-Path: 13249 9002 8744 48485
Community: 3254:65535 3254:9100 3524:9111

but when I'm trying to get all routes with selected community, I get strange results.

None for 3254:9111 :

eel.36 # show bgp routes community 3254 : 9111

Feasible Routes
---------------
Destination Peer Next-Hop LPref Weight MED AS-Path


Unfeasible Routes
-----------------
Destination Peer Next-Hop LPref Weight MED AS-Path

while everything is ok for 3254:9100:

eel.60 # show bgp routes community 3254 : 9100

Feasible Routes
---------------
Destination Peer Next-Hop LPref Weight MED AS-Path
*>i 1.0.4.0/22 194.44.35.213 194.44.35.213 90 1 3255 6939 7545 7545 7545 7545 7545 56203
i 1.0.4.0/22 213.133.164.149 213.133.164.149 85 1 100 13249 6939 7545 7545 7545 7545 7545 56203
*>i 1.5.0.0/16 194.44.35.213 194.44.35.213 90 1 3255 6939 4725
i 1.5.0.0/16 213.133.164.149 213.133.164.149 85 1 100 13249 6939 4725
*>i 1.8.1.0/24 194.44.35.213 194.44.35.213 90 1 3255 3549 6453 4641 38345
i 1.8.1.0/24 213.133.164.149 213.133.164.149 85 1 100 13249 6453 4641 38345
*>i 1.8.8.0/24 194.44.35.213 194.44.35.213 90 1 3255 3549 6453 4641 38345
i 1.8.8.0/24 213.133.164.149 213.133.164.149 85 1 100 13249 6453 4641 38345

Everything rest besides "show" seems to be working.

Incoming policy map is:

entry peer-in-50 {
if match any {
as-path "_NNNNN_" ;
community "XXXX:YYYYY" ;
}
then {
local-preference 95;
community set "3254:65535 3254:9100";
community add "3524:9111";
permit;
}
}

Is it bug or feature?

Summit x480
Image : ExtremeXOS version 12.5.1.6 v1251b6 by release-manager
on Tue Nov 23 09:49:14 PST 2010

Thank you



--



/doka



Vision without Execution is Hallucination. -- Thomas Edison.

________________________________

No virus found in this message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com<http://www.avg.com>
Version: 10.0.1390 / Virus Database: 1516/3771 - Release Date: 07/17/11

Erik,

I was trying single "community set" statement like

community set "3254:65535 3254:9100 3254:9111"

with the same result. Since I want to remove all incoming communities, I
use "set" to rewrite entire information.

Actually, this works - because you've seen that particular network
prefix has specific communities. The question is why some of them can't
be used with "show bgp route comm" command.

On 7/18/2011 1:49 PM, Erik Bais wrote:
>
> Hi Doka,
>
> Is there a specific reason why you are using the following syntax for
> the BGP policy to add the communities ?
>
> community set "3254:65535 3254:9100";
> community add "3524:9111";
>
> I’m using the following in my policies :
>
> entry entry-5 {
>
> If {
>
> nlri 123.123.128.0/21 exact ;
>
> }
>
> then {
>
> med set 0;
>
> local-preference 250;
>
> community add "51088:6543" ;
>
> community add "51088:65001" ;
>
> permit ;
>
> }
>
> }
>
> And that works on 12.4.2 , 12.4.3, 12.5.4. (and is currently broken
> in the 12.6.x beta but expected to be fixed before the 12.6 GA version.)
>
> I’m also running X480’s .
>
> Regards,
>
> Erik Bais
>
> *From:*extreme-nsp-bounces@puck.nether.net
> [mailto:extreme-nsp-bounces@puck.nether.net] *On Behalf Of *Volodymyr
> Litovka
> *Sent:* Monday, July 18, 2011 12:35 PM
> *To:* extreme-nsp@puck.nether.net
> *Cc:* yokodzun@yokodzun.kiev.ua
> *Subject:* [e-nsp] ExOS: "sh bgp routes community" bug?
>
> Hi,
>
> when looking into detailed network info, it shows right communities here:
>
> _eel.35 # sh bgp routes detail network 31.41.120.0/21_
>
> Feasible Routes
> ---------------
> Route: 31.41.120.0/21, Peer 213.133.164.149, BEST, Active
> Origin IGP, Next-Hop 213.133.164.149, LPref 95, MED 100
> Weight 1,
> AS-Path: 13249 9002 8744 48485
> Community: 3254:65535 3254:9100 3524:9111
>
> but when I'm trying to get all routes with selected community, I get
> strange results.
>
> None for 3254:9111 :
>
> _eel.36 # show bgp routes community 3254 : 9111__
> _
> Feasible Routes
> ---------------
> Destination Peer Next-Hop LPref Weight MED AS-Path
>
>
> Unfeasible Routes
> -----------------
> Destination Peer Next-Hop LPref Weight MED AS-Path
>
> while everything is ok for 3254:9100:
>
> _eel.60 # show bgp routes community 3254 : 9100_
>
> Feasible Routes
> ---------------
> Destination Peer Next-Hop LPref Weight
> MED AS-Path
> *>i 1.0.4.0/22 194.44.35.213 194.44.35.213 90
> 1 3255 6939 7545 7545 7545 7545 7545 56203
> i 1.0.4.0/22 213.133.164.149 213.133.164.149 85 1
> 100 13249 6939 7545 7545 7545 7545 7545 56203
> *>i 1.5.0.0/16 194.44.35.213 194.44.35.213 90
> 1 3255 6939 4725
> i 1.5.0.0/16 213.133.164.149 213.133.164.149 85 1
> 100 13249 6939 4725
> *>i 1.8.1.0/24 194.44.35.213 194.44.35.213 90
> 1 3255 3549 6453 4641 38345
> i 1.8.1.0/24 213.133.164.149 213.133.164.149 85 1
> 100 13249 6453 4641 38345
> *>i 1.8.8.0/24 194.44.35.213 194.44.35.213 90
> 1 3255 3549 6453 4641 38345
> i 1.8.8.0/24 213.133.164.149 213.133.164.149 85 1
> 100 13249 6453 4641 38345
>
> Everything rest besides "show" seems to be working.
>
> Incoming policy map is:
>
> entry peer-in-50 {
> if match any {
> as-path "_NNNNN_" ;
> community "XXXX:YYYYY" ;
> }
> then {
> local-preference 95;
> community set "3254:65535 3254:9100";
> community add "3524:9111";
> permit;
> }
> }
>
> Is it bug or feature?
>
> Summit x480
> Image : ExtremeXOS version 12.5.1.6 v1251b6 by release-manager
> on Tue Nov 23 09:49:14 PST 2010
>
> Thank you
>
>
> --
>
> /doka
>
> Vision without Execution is Hallucination. -- Thomas Edison.
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> No virus found in this message.
> Checked by AVG - www.avg.com <http://www.avg.com>
> Version: 10.0.1390 / Virus Database: 1516/3771 - Release Date: 07/17/11
>

--

/doka

Vision without Execution is Hallucination. -- Thomas Edison.

On Mon, 2011-07-18 at 13:34 +0300, Volodymyr Litovka wrote:

> eel.35 # sh bgp routes detail network 31.41.120.0/21
>
> Feasible Routes
> ---------------
> Route: 31.41.120.0/21, Peer 213.133.164.149, BEST, Active
> Origin IGP, Next-Hop 213.133.164.149, LPref 95, MED 100
> Weight 1,
> AS-Path: 13249 9002 8744 48485
> Community: 3254:65535 3254:9100 3524:9111

The community shown here is 3*52*4:9111

> but when I'm trying to get all routes with selected community, I get
> strange results.
>
> None for 3254:9111 :
>
> eel.36 # show bgp routes community 3254 : 9111
>
> Feasible Routes
> ---------------
> Destination Peer Next-Hop LPref Weight MED AS-Path

But you're looking for 3*25*4:9111

Typo?

--
Robert Kerr

_______________________________________________
extreme-nsp mailing list
extreme-nsp@puck.nether.net
https://puck.nether.net/mailman/listinfo/extreme-nsp

Robert,

thanks! You are very attentive - there was really typo :-)

On 7/19/2011 11:47 AM, Robert Kerr wrote:
> On Mon, 2011-07-18 at 13:34 +0300, Volodymyr Litovka wrote:
>
>> eel.35 # sh bgp routes detail network 31.41.120.0/21
>>
>> Feasible Routes
>> ---------------
>> Route: 31.41.120.0/21, Peer 213.133.164.149, BEST, Active
>> Origin IGP, Next-Hop 213.133.164.149, LPref 95, MED 100
>> Weight 1,
>> AS-Path: 13249 9002 8744 48485
>> Community: 3254:65535 3254:9100 3524:9111
> The community shown here is 3*52*4:9111
>
>> but when I'm trying to get all routes with selected community, I get
>> strange results.
>>
>> None for 3254:9111 :
>>
>> eel.36 # show bgp routes community 3254 : 9111
>>
>> Feasible Routes
>> ---------------
>> Destination Peer Next-Hop LPref Weight MED AS-Path
> But you're looking for 3*25*4:9111
>
> Typo?
>

--

/doka

Vision without Execution is Hallucination. -- Thomas Edison.

_______________________________________________
extreme-nsp mailing list
extreme-nsp@puck.nether.net
https://puck.nether.net/mailman/listinfo/extreme-nsp