Hi people.
This is my first post to wikitech-l, and its a biggun. I've
been mulling over this idea for a while now and have finally
gotten the electrons moving...
I propose a number of changes to the Wikipedia software to
enable "software assisted context resolution", or if you
prefer "software assisted disambiguation". The primary purpose
of these changes is to allow users to more easily resolve
ambiguous links at the time they are created, or if necessary,
at some later stage. I stress that this is not "automatic"
link resolution, although the process will be invoked
automatically in many cases.
The process, detailed below, is invoked in two ways. The
first would be manually and explicitly by the user. The
secound would be automatic when an article with new or
modified links it saved.
To enable this process to be invoked manually I propose that
a new meta-link be added to the footer of every page that
contains at least one link (most pages). IMHO, an appropriate
position would be between "Edit this page" and "Discuss this
page". It would read "Resolve links", and invoke a page titled
"Resolving links from (real title)". This new page would look
identical to the original except that the destination of each
link is changed to a "context selection" page as detailed below.
Note that it is entirely possible (and probable) that many links
will point to UNambiguous pages. "Context selection" pages will
still be generated for these links as the user may have found
the first instance of ambiguity and will need to deal with it.
The "context resolution" process would also be invoked when an
article is saved, and the article contains new or modified
links. In this case the "context resolution" page would not be
a mimic of the real page. Rather, a short list of new or modified
links would be generated in the form of an alphabetized list.
The "context selection" pages are generated from the articles
currently known as "disambiguation pages". The bulleted list
found in these articles is transformed into a set of radio
buttons. In addition, a radio button is generated that basically
means "unresolved". At the bottom of this list is a small form
to allow new links and associated context descriptions to be
added. Whichever option is selected from this page, the link in
the calling page is adjusted to point to the selected destination
article, with the original text preserved by using the pipe trick.
A by-product of these changes will be that the "context selection"
pages will, in the main, be updated by the wiki software (as
opposed to hand editted). This should make it possible to more
tightly control the layout of these pages, perhaps with the
addition of subheadings like "People", "Places", "Things".
Further, when the "Edit this page" link is clicked on a "context
selection" page, the normal edit page is replaced by a purpose-
built form for editing such pages.
I understand that there are probably a millions reasons why some
aspect(s) of the above will be difficult or impracticable. I hope
that the general concept is possible and feasible.
Gary Curtis
[[User:Gaz]] on Wiki
<wikiman.at.freemail.dot.com.dot.au> for all Wiki email
--------------------------------------------------------
Looking for a free email account?
Get one now at http://www.freemail.com.au/
--------------------------------------------------------
This is my first post to wikitech-l, and its a biggun. I've
been mulling over this idea for a while now and have finally
gotten the electrons moving...
I propose a number of changes to the Wikipedia software to
enable "software assisted context resolution", or if you
prefer "software assisted disambiguation". The primary purpose
of these changes is to allow users to more easily resolve
ambiguous links at the time they are created, or if necessary,
at some later stage. I stress that this is not "automatic"
link resolution, although the process will be invoked
automatically in many cases.
The process, detailed below, is invoked in two ways. The
first would be manually and explicitly by the user. The
secound would be automatic when an article with new or
modified links it saved.
To enable this process to be invoked manually I propose that
a new meta-link be added to the footer of every page that
contains at least one link (most pages). IMHO, an appropriate
position would be between "Edit this page" and "Discuss this
page". It would read "Resolve links", and invoke a page titled
"Resolving links from (real title)". This new page would look
identical to the original except that the destination of each
link is changed to a "context selection" page as detailed below.
Note that it is entirely possible (and probable) that many links
will point to UNambiguous pages. "Context selection" pages will
still be generated for these links as the user may have found
the first instance of ambiguity and will need to deal with it.
The "context resolution" process would also be invoked when an
article is saved, and the article contains new or modified
links. In this case the "context resolution" page would not be
a mimic of the real page. Rather, a short list of new or modified
links would be generated in the form of an alphabetized list.
The "context selection" pages are generated from the articles
currently known as "disambiguation pages". The bulleted list
found in these articles is transformed into a set of radio
buttons. In addition, a radio button is generated that basically
means "unresolved". At the bottom of this list is a small form
to allow new links and associated context descriptions to be
added. Whichever option is selected from this page, the link in
the calling page is adjusted to point to the selected destination
article, with the original text preserved by using the pipe trick.
A by-product of these changes will be that the "context selection"
pages will, in the main, be updated by the wiki software (as
opposed to hand editted). This should make it possible to more
tightly control the layout of these pages, perhaps with the
addition of subheadings like "People", "Places", "Things".
Further, when the "Edit this page" link is clicked on a "context
selection" page, the normal edit page is replaced by a purpose-
built form for editing such pages.
I understand that there are probably a millions reasons why some
aspect(s) of the above will be difficult or impracticable. I hope
that the general concept is possible and feasible.
Gary Curtis
[[User:Gaz]] on Wiki
<wikiman.at.freemail.dot.com.dot.au> for all Wiki email
--------------------------------------------------------
Looking for a free email account?
Get one now at http://www.freemail.com.au/
--------------------------------------------------------