Mailing List Archive

Re: Wikitech-l digest, Vol 1 #328 - 11 msgs
Message: 3
Subject: Re: [Wikitech-l] Alternative proposal for
interlanguage links
redesign and a few other issues
From: Erik Moeller <e.moeller@fokus.gmd.de>
To: wikitech-l@wikipedia.org
Organization: FOKUS
Date: 08 Jan 2003 14:55:32 +0100
Reply-To: wikitech-l@wikipedia.org
On Die, 2003-01-07 at 19:07, Tomasz Wegrzanowski
wrote:
> 1. move everything to Postgres
> 2. move everything to common database, with tables
foo_cur, foo_old
etc.,
> where foo are language names
> 3. make single user table (needs some tweaking to
allow slightly
different
> preferences), single logging system, single
recent changes, and
all other
> nice things we can do with that
> 4. move everything to UTF-8, so we don't have to use
%escapes in
English Wikipedia

I would appreciate very much that you explain to me
very clearly what will be the benefits of switching to
UTF 8. I have no idea, and it must be important if you
think of moving everything this way.

As I understood, meta is coded in UTF-8.

I'll be very clear why this is an important matter to
me : if you move everything to UTF-8, I will just quit
Wikipedia.

The only place I can write properly on the meta is
from work (W2k and IE). And my boss doesn't appreciate
that much.

At home, I can't write any special characters; and if
I edit a page with some (for exemple "accueil" our
home page), I mess everything. It is a matte of
importance in french language.

Opera doesn't support UTF. Netscape doesn't support
some of our characters either, and is all crazy with
the frames (tool bar unusable). And from time to time,
IE refuse to edit long windows (it doesnot cut them as
Opera does, it just displays the visible part of the
edit window, the scrollbar just disappears). And
Mozilla is not working well, and real slow. So the
easiest way to me is to write with no accents. And
never edit pages with special characters.

I can't find a really satisfying option. It is not a
huge problem on meta. But it definitly would make
working on wikipedia articles a real pain. So please,
explain what the real benefits are, and don't make the
switch just a minor issue.
At least on the french one.
It won't be so bad on the english one, for you don't
use special characters much, but likely many people
will have to correct things after me. So, maybe I'll
give up participating on the en.wiki.

__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now.
http://mailplus.yahoo.com
Re: Re: Wikitech-l digest, Vol 1 #328 - 11 msgs [ In reply to ]
On Thu, Jan 09, 2003 at 04:39:51AM -0800, Anthere wrote:
> > 4. move everything to UTF-8, so we don't have to use
> %escapes in
> English Wikipedia
>
> I would appreciate very much that you explain to me
> very clearly what will be the benefits of switching to
> UTF 8. I have no idea, and it must be important if you
> think of moving everything this way.
>
> As I understood, meta is coded in UTF-8.
>
> I'll be very clear why this is an important matter to
> me : if you move everything to UTF-8, I will just quit
> Wikipedia.
>
> The only place I can write properly on the meta is
> from work (W2k and IE). And my boss doesn't appreciate
> that much.
>
> At home, I can't write any special characters; and if
> I edit a page with some (for exemple "accueil" our
> home page), I mess everything. It is a matte of
> importance in french language.
>
> Opera doesn't support UTF. Netscape doesn't support
> some of our characters either, and is all crazy with
> the frames (tool bar unusable). And from time to time,
> IE refuse to edit long windows (it doesnot cut them as
> Opera does, it just displays the visible part of the
> edit window, the scrollbar just disappears). And
> Mozilla is not working well, and real slow. So the
> easiest way to me is to write with no accents. And
> never edit pages with special characters.

Opera, Mozilla, IE, Netscape and Konqueror ALL SUPPORT UTF-8.
I have used them all to edit Polish Wikipedia
(which is UTF-8) and had never any problems about that.

Opera has broken charset autodetection, you may
wish to play with settings a bit.

Other problems you describe have nothing to do with UTF-8.

If it realy doesn't work, try upgrading your browser.

> I can't find a really satisfying option. It is not a
> huge problem on meta. But it definitly would make
> working on wikipedia articles a real pain. So please,
> explain what the real benefits are, and don't make the
> switch just a minor issue.
> At least on the french one.
> It won't be so bad on the english one, for you don't
> use special characters much, but likely many people
> will have to correct things after me. So, maybe I'll
> give up participating on the en.wiki.

One reason are Interwiki links, which now must be coded
by %-sequences, and making en->pl links is very inconvenient,
especially when using konqueror, which displays normal
characters, not %-sequences in URL bar.


But the really important one is that we really need
characters outside ISO-8859-1.

How can I write article about any Polish city if I can't
write half of Polish diactrics ? The same applies to most
of central Europe, and to most romanizations schemes of other
scripts (which use lot of diactrics).
How can I write any article about people from such places ?
Engish Wikipedia screws this issue completely by stripping
essential diactrics (like http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lech_Walesa).

How can I write article about some language that doesn't
use ISO-8859-1 (that's some 90% of world languages) ?
Polish Wikipedia contains more linguistic information
than English now, mostly because you can't do any decent
linguistics without using native scripts. Even if I wanted
to translate Polish articles to English, I wouldn't be able
to put them on English Wikipedia.
Re: Re: Wikitech-l digest, Vol 1 #328 - 11 msgs [ In reply to ]
Anthere wrote:

>
>The only place I can write properly on the meta is
>from work (W2k and IE). And my boss doesn't appreciate
>that much.
>
>At home, I can't write any special characters; and if
>I edit a page with some (for exemple "accueil" our
>home page), I mess everything. It is a matte of
>importance in french language.
>
>
What is your OS at home?
I have Win 98 SE and the Polish wikipedia looks ok in both Mozilla & IE.

(not tried editing though -- what's "sandbox" in polish? could we put
language links on the sandbox pages?)

>
>
Re: Re: Wikitech-l digest, Vol 1 #328 - 11 msgs [ In reply to ]
On Thu, Jan 09, 2003 at 01:50:31PM +0000, tarquin wrote:
> (not tried editing though -- what's "sandbox" in polish? could we put
> language links on the sandbox pages?)

http://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Brudnopis
Re: Wikitech-l digest, Vol 1 #328 - 11 msgs [ In reply to ]
On Thu, 9 Jan 2003 04:39:51 -0800 (PST), Anthere
<anthere5=/E1597aS9LQAvxtiuMwx3w@public.gmane.org> wrote:

> At home, I can't write any special characters; and if
> I edit a page with some (for exemple "accueil" our
> home page), I mess everything. It is a matte of
> importance in french language.
>
> Opera doesn't support UTF.

Pardon me, but from version 6 onwards Opera not only supports UTF, but
every single string is converted to UTF for it's internal processing!

--
Richard Grevers
Christchurch, New Zealand