It is now Tuesday, May 19, 2020, 8:46 AM GMT.
A re-spin of the vote closing/ summary.
48 votes have been posted: 37 from PMC members, 8 from committers and
3 from user community.
From this total 8 people voted -1 and 40 people voted +1. Vote
distribution among PMC members (binding votes):
[+1]: 33
[-1]: 4
The vote has passed.
Dawid
All collected votes in a spreadsheet:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ZmR3C2EgA57QIeJJ3ejKCTUkHdG1lqPOU29heqybkKs/edit?usp=sharing And in plain text:
+1
PMC Ishan Chattopadhyaya (ichattopadhyaya@gmail.com)
PMC Doron Cohen (cdoronc@gmail.com)
PMC Shai Erera (serera@gmail.com)
PMC Ryan Ernst (ryan@iernst.net)
COMMITTER Jim Ferenczi (jim.ferenczi@gmail.com)
PMC Otis Gospodnetic (otis.gospodnetic@gmail.com)
PMC Dennis Gove (dpgove@gmail.com)
PMC Adrien Grand (jpountz@gmail.com)
PMC Martijn v Groningen (martijn.v.groningen@gmail.com)
PMC Mark Harwood (mharwood@apache.org)
PMC Erik Hatcher (erik.hatcher@gmail.com)
PMC Shawn Heisey (apache@elyograg.org)
PMC Jan Høydahl (jan.asf@cominvent.com)
COMMITTER Namgyu Kim (kng0828@gmail.com)
PMC Nicholas Knize (nknize@gmail.com)
PMC Shalin Shekhar Mangar (shalinmangar@gmail.com)
PMC Michael McCandless (lucene@mikemccandless.com)
PMC Christian Moen (cm@atilika.com)
-- Gora Mohanty (gora@mimirtech.com)
PMC Robert Muir (rcmuir@gmail.com)
PMC Nhat Nguyen (nhat.nguyen@elastic.co.invalid)
PMC Kevin Risden (krisden@apache.org)
PMC Steven A Rowe (sarowe@gmail.com)
PMC Uwe Schindler (uwe@thetaphi.de)
PMC Koji Sekiguchi (koji.sekiguchi@rondhuit.com)
COMMITTER Atri Sharma (atri@apache.org)
-- Lucky Sharma (goku0910@gmail.com)
PMC David Smiley (david.w.smiley@gmail.com)
COMMITTER Michael Sokolov (msokolov@gmail.com)
PMC Tommaso Teofili (tommaso.teofili@gmail.com)
PMC Varun Thacker (varun@vthacker.in)
COMMITTER Tomoko Uchida (tomoko.uchida.1111@gmail.com)
PMC Andi Vajda (osaf@ovaltofu.org)
PMC Ignacio Vera (iverase@gmail.com)
PMC Dawid Weiss (dawid.weiss@gmail.com)
PMC Simon Willnauer (simon.willnauer@gmail.com)
PMC Alan Woodward (romseygeek@gmail.com)
PMC Karl Wright (daddywri@gmail.com)
COMMITTER Alexandre Rafalovitch (arafalov@gmail.com)
PMC Andrzej Bia?ecki (ab@getopt.org)
-1
PMC Joel Bernstein (joelsolr@gmail.com)
COMMITTER Mike Drob (mdrob@apache.org)
PMC Jason Gerlowski (gerlowskija@gmail.com)
PMC Anshum Gupta (anshum@anshumgupta.net)
COMMITTER Gus Heck (gus.heck@gmail.com)
COMMITTER Chris Hostetter (hossman_lucene@fucit.org)
PMC Tomás Fernández Löbbe (tomasflobbe@gmail.com)
-- Kevin Watters (kwatters@kmwllc.com)
On Tue, May 12, 2020 at 9:36 AM Dawid Weiss <dawid.weiss@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Dear Lucene and Solr developers!
>
> According to an earlier [DISCUSS] thread on the dev list [2], I am
> calling for a vote on the proposal to make Solr a top-level Apache
> project (TLP) and separate Lucene and Solr development into two
> independent entities.
>
> To quickly recap the reasons and consequences of such a move: it seems
> like the reasons for the initial merge of Lucene and Solr, around 10
> years ago, have been achieved. Both projects are in good shape and
> exhibit signs of independence already (mailing lists, committers,
> patch flow). There are many technical considerations that would make
> development much easier if we move Solr out into its own TLP.
>
> We discussed this issue [2] and both PMC members and committers had a
> chance to review all the pros and cons and express their views. The
> discussion showed that there are clearly different opinions on the
> matter - some people are in favor, some are neutral, others are
> against or not seeing the point of additional labor. Realistically, I
> don't think reaching 100% level consensus is going to be possible --
> we are a diverse bunch with different opinions and personalities. I
> firmly believe this is the right direction hence the decision to put
> it under the voting process. Should something take a wrong turn in the
> future (as some folks worry it may), all blame is on me.
>
> Therefore, the proposal is to separate Solr from under Lucene TLP, and
> make it a TLP on its own. The initial structure of the new PMC,
> committer base, git repositories and other managerial aspects can be
> worked out during the process if the decision passes.
>
> Please indicate one of the following (see [1] for guidelines):
>
> [ ] +1 - yes, I vote for the proposal
> [ ] -1 - no, I vote against the proposal
>
> Please note that anyone in the Lucene+Solr community is invited to
> express their opinion, though only Lucene+Solr committers cast binding
> votes (indicate non-binding votes in your reply, please).
>
> The vote will be active for a week to give everyone a chance to read
> and cast a vote.
>
> Dawid
>
> [1] https://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html
> [2] https://lists.apache.org/thread.html/rfae2440264f6f874e91545b2030c98e7b7e3854ddf090f7747d338df%40%3Cdev.lucene.apache.org%3E
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@lucene.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@lucene.apache.org